• Home
  • About Alex Wild
  • Articles
  • Galleries
  • Myrmecology News

Myrmecos Blog

the little things matter

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Random associations of photo and story
A Song for your Sunday »

Why Ants are Cooler than Flies

September 20, 2008 by myrmecos

Dipterist Keith Bayless exposes a pernicious case of media bias:

Six new families of Diptera were described from newly discovered species in the last 6 years! None of these flies received the press coverage given to Martialis. There are a variety of explanations for this, including that

1) The fly descriptions were published in lower profile journals than PNAS
2) Many of the the new fly families evolved more recently than the first ant in the Martialis lineage
3) The level of public and scientific interest in ants inclines them to be better covered or
4) People who study ants are better at public relations.

I think Keith misses an even larger issue. For most people, the Linnean category of “family” doesn’t mean anything.  Joe Public has no reason to know that all ants are classified as a family while all flies are an order containing many families.  Instead, people tend to shoehorn nature into a set of basic types of organisms.  These types match, more or less, the set of heavily used common names.  As any taxonomist knows, the correspondence between the public’s conception of basic types does not have to correspond to any particular taxonomic rank.  Cockroaches (Blattaria) are an entire order; Mosquitoes (Culicidae) are a family; Cows (Bos taurus) are a species.

Hence, “ants” are seen as a basic kind of organism, so are “flies”, and “squirrels”, and “squid” and so forth.  As an aside, the innate ability of the human brain to simplify nature into arbitrary categories is a major reason-if not the major reason- for the persistent appeal of creationism.  But I digress.

The consequence is that a newly discovered sister lineage to a basic “kind” of organism- an ant- will generate more buzz than the announcement of new lineages buried deep within another basic “kind” or organism- a fly.

Now, I happen to think this is an asinine way to approach biodiversity.  But no one put me in charge of designing human cognition, and I can’t fault the vast majority of the human population that doesn’t spend much time thinking about insects for taking mental shortcuts.

A second factor is the ease with which ants are anthropomorphized.  While the actual parallels between ant societies and human societies are weak, the fact remains that ants live in groups bearing some superficial resemblance to the way we live.  We relate to ants more easily than to flies.  So Hollywood makes movies about ants.  About flies, not so much.  And papers touting a new ant lineage make PNAS.  That’s why I think Keith’s #3 should top the list, and points 1 and 4 are mere correlates.  In the end, Dipterists face a much steeper uphill battle for popular recognition than we myrmecologists.

It should go without saying that this is deeply unfair to Dipterists, whose subjects really are one of life’s most fantastic productions.   But hey, it could be worse.  Think of the poor Psocopterists.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Ants, Insect Links, Photography Links, Science, Taxonomy | Tagged Biology Links, entomology, Flies, media bias | 14 Comments

14 Responses

  1. on September 20, 2008 at 12:21 pm Mom

    Hey, what’s a Psocopterist?


  2. on September 20, 2008 at 6:23 pm Benny

    Keith also forgot to mention that flies are totally lame.


  3. on September 20, 2008 at 9:33 pm ardeans

    Flies are the largest land animal in Antarctica. End of story. (but Hymenoptera are cooler, sorry Keith)


  4. on September 20, 2008 at 9:58 pm Beetles In The Bush

    Not to play devil’s advocate, but quick – name the coolest insect movie ever. “The Fly”! Maybe I missed it, but I don’t recall ever seeing “The Ant” 😉


  5. on September 21, 2008 at 6:40 am Beetles In The Bush

    p.s. Incredible photo!


  6. on September 21, 2008 at 7:14 am asj

    You missed the simplest explanation: common people are kinda disgusted by flies (myself included) and not by ants. Maybe it’s the fact flies are found so readily in, well, “disgusting” places 😉


  7. on September 21, 2008 at 12:21 pm John

    Ants can’t fly but flies can, so flies are cooler.🙂


  8. on September 21, 2008 at 6:58 pm everyoneelse

    Geez, ants are tiny, and yet they still kill and eat big animals. Flies just hope they are dirty enough to make you sick. We vote ANTS, ftw!


  9. on September 22, 2008 at 1:42 am Sheri

    Maybe I missed it, but I don’t recall ever seeing “The Ant”

    Ah, BITB @#4, have you never seen Them! (1954) or Empire of the Ants (1977) on the Late Late Late Late Movie?


  10. on September 22, 2008 at 2:42 am raptorialforetarsi

    Beetles In The Bush:

    Have you ever seen “Them!” ?
    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0047573/

    John: Most ants species reproductives can fly, and some flies can’t…


  11. on September 22, 2008 at 1:57 pm Keith Bayless

    To the anti-fly posts here: “The most ecologically diverse group of insects is certainly the true flies, or Diptera… The true diversity of flies, in fact, probably vies with that of the Coleoptera because there are much higher proportions of undescribed Diptera”- Grimaldi & Engel. 2005. Evolution of the Insects. Anyway, Alex (sorry for putting words in your mouth) and I aren’t saying there’s some kind of intrinsic coolness
    factor for which one group has a higher value, the reasons are instead psychological and sociological. Debating the relative ‘coolness’ of various insect groups is a fun but silly and futile argument that is ultimately detrimental to entomology.

    To Alex- thanks for quoting my post! Those points were off the top of my head, so please forgive the lack of rigorous sociological data. Hmm, you’re right about how the public considers the ‘types’ of organisms. Non-entomologists are always shocked when I tell them that there are 158,000+ described species of flies. I guess they think that flies are one ‘type.’ Some of the comments above me prove your point very well.

    I’d like to also point out that even taxonomic ranks don’t give us a great basis for evolutionary comparison, e.g. the mammal Order Carnivora has ~280 extant species, evolved ~55 mya, and are almost all predators. This is the size and age of a pretty large, not very old, and ecologically monotonous insect genus. A new species of carnivore would be all over the news, though. Benoit gets into this in a comment on my blog post.

    So the discovery of a new fly family and the discovery of the sister group to all other ants are not the same thing in terms of age, number of species involved, and ecological importance. Some might argue successfully that the Martialis discovery is more important than some of the new fly families. Still, how many people have heard of Oreoleptidae before? You will next week!

    Let’s agree that Psocoptera are way cool and mammals don’t match their hype.


  12. on September 22, 2008 at 5:13 pm Why ants are cooler than flies, part 2 (or are they?) « Myrmecos Blog

    […] to our earlier discussion, google search statistics suggest “flies” should be able to hold their own against […]


  13. on September 23, 2008 at 8:40 am asj

    “Non-entomologists are always shocked when I tell them that there are 158,000+ described species of flies.”

    There are 158k described species of flies???!!!!!! 😯

    “and I aren’t saying there’s some kind of intrinsic coolness factor for which one group has a higher value, the reasons are instead psychological and sociological.”

    “coolness” is a result of sociological and psychological factors. To a flower pollinated by flies, flies are way cooler than ants.

    Saying that, there are 158k described species of flies???!!!!!! 😯


  14. on September 25, 2008 at 4:46 pm Wild Light | Wildlife Photography : Insect Art : Bird Art : Honey Bee Art » Ants versus flies

    […] not sure what could be sexier than the mating flies in my last post, but over at the Myrmecos blog, they’ve been discussing “Why Ants are Cooler than […]



Comments are closed.


  • This blog is an archive; the Myrmecos blog has moved.

    Please update your bookmarks!
  • Alex’s Galleries

    alexanderwild.com

  • Recent Photos

    Autumn MemoriesSneak PeekPoppies in TuscanySomething's brewing in the Sky - #explored 30.06.22⭐ Puesta de sol entre palmeras //Sunset between palm trees (EXPLORE 30/06/2022).Milky Way at Lake Norring, Western Australia
    More Photos
  • Biology Links

    • Tree of Life
    • Understanding Evolution
  • Blogroll

    • Ainsley Vs Livejournal
    • Ammonite
    • Anna’s Bee World
    • Archetype
    • Arthropoda blog
    • Backyard Arthropod Project
    • Beetles in the Bush
    • biodiversity in focus
    • Bug Dreams
    • Bug Eric
    • Bug Girl’s Blog
    • Burrard-Lucas Photoblog
    • Catalogue of Organisms
    • Creature Cast
    • Dan Heller
    • Debbie's Insect Blog
    • Dechronization
    • Drawing the MotMot
    • Entomoblog
    • Evolving Thoughts
    • Fall to Climb
    • Generant
    • Historias de Hormigas
    • Life on Six Legs
    • Macromite
    • microecos
    • mirmekolozi
    • myrmecoid
    • Myrmician
    • Natural Imagery
    • Nature in the Ozarks
    • NCSU Insect Blog
    • No Cropping Zone
    • omit needless words
    • Photo Synthesis
    • Princess Peppercloud
    • Science Blogs
    • Snail’s Tales
    • Stu Jenks
    • The Ant Hunter
    • The Ant Room
    • The Bug Whisperer
    • The Loom
    • This Week in Evolution
    • What's Bugging You?
    • Wild about Ants
    • Xenogere
  • Insect Links

    • Ant Farm Forum
    • Ant Insights
    • Antweb
    • Bug Squad
    • bugguide.net
    • Xerces Society
  • Photography Links

    • Canon Photography Forums
    • Digital Photography Review
    • DIY Photography
    • Igor Siwanowicz
    • Mark Plonsky
    • photo.net
    • Piotr Naskrecki
    • The Strobist
  • Popular Posts

    • How to Identify the Argentine Ant, Linepithema humile
    • How to Identify Queen Ants
    • About Alex Wild
    • Friday Beetle Blogging: the Pink Glow-Worm
    • Things that look like ants but aren't (Part 1)
    • The eggs that weren't
    • North America's charming citronella ants
    • Homage to a Myrmecologist
    • Shattuck revises the Australian Army Ants
    • Eureka! Heureka! An Astonishing New Ant!
  • Recent Posts

    • This blog has moved.
    • Friday Beetle Blogging: The Hollyhock Weevil
    • The Friday Beetle will be late…
    • Bed bugs reach an all-time high
    • Answer to the Monday Night Mystery
  • Recent Comments

    • Donald Byron Johnson on Reader question: who discovered the sex of ant workers?
    • Anonymous on Update on the Rogue Taxonomist
    • Ant on Arizona Daily Star covers “Planet of the Ants”
    • Ga. Girl on Beware the Cow-Killer
    • Anonymous on Beware the Cow-Killer
  • Categories

  • Archives

  • animation Ants aphids arachnids Argentina arizona army ants art Bees beetles behavior biodiversity biology Biology Links bugs Canon carabidae coleoptera copyright Darwin desert diptera E. O. Wilson ecology entomology Evolution fail fire ants Flies formicidae genetics google haiku Harpegnathos imaging Insect Links Insects invasive species lighting Linepithema macro macrophotography macro photography Martialis media miniscule muppets music myrmecology mystery natural history Nature new species odontomachus Parasites Paratrechina pests pheidole Photography Photography business photoshop phylogenetics phylogeny Pogonomyrmex politics predation Scarabaeidae Science SEM social insects spiders Taxonomy termites travel wasps
  • Nature Blog Network
    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Follow this blog

Blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Myrmecos Blog
    • Join 90 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Myrmecos Blog
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: