• Home
  • About Alex Wild
  • Articles
  • Galleries
  • Myrmecology News

Myrmecos Blog

the little things matter

Feeds:
Posts
Comments
« Native ants on introduced nectaries
The Odorous House Ant, Tapinoma sessile »

A Guide to the Insect Field Guides of North America

May 19, 2009 by myrmecos

Eli

The summer insect season is upon us here in temperate North America, and with it comes the need for good identification guides.

Before I begin, a cautionary note.  We have so many species on our continent that were we to create a bird-type guide that listed all the insects, with their ranges and identifying characteristics, the full set would span at least 30 volumes.   Any book small enough to carry into the field necessarily omits more than 95% of the relevant animals.  Insect guides are understandably neurotic and overwhelmed compared to the corresponding bird and plant guides, and it’s worth remembering that guides represent the author’s judgment about which species are the most likely to be encountered.  With no guarantee, of course, that the mysterious bug in your hand is common.  Proper identification to species normally requires examination of a preserved specimen under high magnification with reference to the original taxonomic literature.

Having said all that though, let’s throw caution to the wind.  Here is my completely biased opinion* of the most prominent North American insect guides.

Kaufman1Kaufman Field Guide to Insects of North America.  The Kaufman guide was only published in the last couple years, but in that short period has become the first book I consult.   The reason is simple. This guide, written by Eric Eaton and Kenn Kaufman, makes no bones about being strictly an identification tool.  The pages are packed with stylized photos, stripped from their habitats and laid out next to each other for easier identification.  By skimping on the amount of text provided for each species, Eaton & Kaufman cover a broader array of species than competing guides- more than twice the number as the NWF guide, in fact.  An insect is more likely to show up in the pages of this guide than any other. Of course, the lack of accompanying biological detail is frustrating, but that’s the price of achieving both the smallest size and the greatest coverage. Highly recommended.

nwf1National Wildlife Federation Field Guide to Insects and Spiders of North America. This handsome volume, authored by Art Evans, stands out for the depth of information provided for the illustrated species.  The photographs- many taken by the author- depict animals in their habitat, and the guide is among the most aesthetically pleasing books on the market.  The inevitable trade-off of providing more text per species is that fewer species are covered.  The NWF guide is not as likely to lead the reader to an identified insect as is the Kaufman guide, but the natural history detail in the text is much more satisfying for those insects that are included. Highly recommended.

nas1National Audubon Society Field Guide to Insects and Spiders. Decades out of date, riddled with creative misidentifications, and arranged in an utterly nonsensical manner, this book will provide hours of surreal amusement.  Some bugs are included with the beetles.  There are moths in the wasps, and flies in the bees, except for the ones placed with the ticks.  Or spiders.  In the book’s defense, the faux-leather binding is flexible and durable in the field, perhaps the most field-worthy of the lot, so you’ll be able to abuse this book for years and still be able to misidentify your insects just as easily as when it was new.  My advice?  Don’t bother.  Not recommended.

peterson1Peterson’s A Field Guide to Insects.  Peterson’s is the grandaddy of insect guides, now several decades past the original printing and slipping out of date, and digestable only by the already entomologically literate.  The vocabulary is technical, some of the characters arcane, and the illustrations are based on preserved specimens rather than live insects.  Non-specialists may lack the technical chops to properly use this guide. Or is it another sign that today’s kids just aren’t as smart as they used to be?  But I digress. For the persistent naturalist, the Peterson’s Guide offers the best hope for identifying rare and unusual insects short of consulting the original taxonomic monographs.  It’s a rigorous, professional, and satisfying guide.  If you’ve already passed Ent 101, that is.  Recommended only for more advanced users.

*disclaimer: The Kaufman and the NWF guide both licensed images from myrmecos.net in exchange for fistfuls of cash.

Share this:

  • Twitter
  • Facebook

Like this:

Like Loading...

Related

Posted in Science, Taxonomy | Tagged entomology, field guides, Insects, Nature | 15 Comments

15 Responses

  1. on May 19, 2009 at 8:45 am Alex/Watcher

    A very helpful post and timely, as I’m an amateur in the market for a new guide. Glad to see your strong recommendation for the Kaufman; it’s my favorite bird guide. Thanks!


  2. on May 19, 2009 at 8:53 am Ted C. MacRae

    Nice review, Alex – and I couldn’t agree more with your recommendations. I think Audubon was trying to make theirs so it could be used in the same way their wildflower guides are used, with arrangments based on appearances only and having nothing to do with any taxonomic relationships. A backwards approach, in my opinion, since gaining awareness of the taxonomic distinctions allows users to eventually ID the many species they will encounter that are not in the guide at least down to family level. I never even look at it anymore.

    But, you left out one of my favorites: Golden Nature Guide, Insects, by Herbert Zim & Clarence Cottam. Surely not competetive with the guides you review here, but as a child discovering the world of insects, that book was my bible. I had the 1956 edition, and it survives to this day in my library, its binding taped and retaped from the heavy use it received those many years ago. Those stylized paintings of dog day cicadas, harlequin bugs, and green June beetles are still burned in my memory.


  3. on May 19, 2009 at 9:04 am Ted C. MacRae

    p.s. the child with net photo is outstanding!


    • on May 22, 2009 at 8:30 am Ant

      Heh, that’s like me when I was a kid!


  4. on May 19, 2009 at 9:15 am Chanda

    Thank you oh so much!!!


  5. on May 19, 2009 at 12:21 pm Marc "Teleutotje" Van der Stappen

    You may think it’s funny but, as a European, I’m a proud owner of a Peterson’s Field Guide to the Insects of North America (an edition from the 80’s!) and I’m not only using it here in Belgium but I also recommend it to others. Yes I know that the systematics are on some places outdated and Europe isn’t North America but …..
    For a quick field guide I still find it one of the best and, if you know where the systematics have changed, one of the best to place insects you can find in the field. And, strange but true, even European insects. Yes, some groups are not known in North America but if you know that …..
    And I like the methods in it, a line that points to the most important characteristics of the group they discuss, some small remarks about similar groups, little info about ecology, …..
    It can compete with some of the best European guides and from some of them it wins with a big Hoeray!


  6. on May 19, 2009 at 2:58 pm Kai

    Then, of course, there’s the Borrow and Delong’s Introduction to the insects; while some of the keys are downright horrible to work through (Coleoptera anyone?), it covers identification for every family of insect in North America.


  7. on May 19, 2009 at 4:07 pm MJ

    “Insects; thier natural history and Diversity” by Stephen A.
    Marshall
    Not exactly a field guide but I pour over it like a kid looking through the window at an array of a candy. I’ve made my wish list from this book and you know what, sometimes I see one of the insects on the wish list just because I’ve ragged eared the pages of this book.


  8. on May 19, 2009 at 4:16 pm myrmecos

    Kai & MJ:

    Both fine suggestions, the Borror and the Marshall. An earlier version of this post included both of those (large & heavy) books, as well as some regional guides and online resources, but then I decided to strip it down to just the guides in “classic” small form.


  9. on May 19, 2009 at 4:25 pm Jason R

    Or is it another sign that today’s kids just aren’t as smart as they used to be? Or maybe it is a sign you are both stupid about different things?

    But seriously, thank for this post. I run into a similar problem when recommending beachcombing guides.


  10. on May 20, 2009 at 6:22 am Danielle Brigida

    Entomology was my favorite subject in college and I really appreciate your break down of these guides (I definitely have a few).

    Thanks for mentioning NWF among the group- I’m definitely bookmarking your blog!


  11. on May 20, 2009 at 7:02 am Tim Eisele

    As far as regional guides go, for our region I like “Insects of the Great Lakes Region” by Gary Dunn, except for one thing: all it has are black-and-white line drawings, no pictures. On the other hand, I suppose this forces the user to focus more on details other than color, which can be useful. I also like that it gives a lot of references to the primary literature, so when the user wants to know more, it is easy enough to follow up. The Kaufman guide makes a really nice mate to it, because it has the pictures but not so much of the descriptions or references.

    I really do like regional guides in general, because I rarely get out of the Great Lakes region, so I don’t really need a field guide that is packed up with all the insects that live in, say, Florida but are never found in Michigan.


  12. on May 23, 2009 at 12:55 pm Euglossine Bee

    Bummer — I own two of these, and not the two you recommend!

    Alleviating the error asap!


  13. on June 1, 2009 at 12:15 am Circus of the Spineless #39 « Bug Girl’s Blog

    […] at Myrmecos provides a Guide to Insect Field Guides! Very helpful and timely, as “What’s that bug?” season is upon us.  Annotated […]


  14. on June 24, 2010 at 1:49 pm Dave Ingram's Natural History Blog :: Book Review – Field Guide to Insects and Spiders of North America

    […] A Guide to the Insect Field Guides of North America over at Myrmecos Blog […]



Comments are closed.


  • This blog is an archive; the Myrmecos blog has moved.

    Please update your bookmarks!
  • Alex’s Galleries

    alexanderwild.com

  • Recent Photos

    DarkQue bonito trabajo el de la Luna...iluminar vidas cuando andan a oscuras.Elephant HeadEastern Coyote, Southern OntarioWindowsジュエリーアイス
    More Photos
  • Biology Links

    • Tree of Life
    • Understanding Evolution
  • Blogroll

    • Ainsley Vs Livejournal
    • Ammonite
    • Anna’s Bee World
    • Archetype
    • Arthropoda blog
    • Backyard Arthropod Project
    • Beetles in the Bush
    • biodiversity in focus
    • Bug Dreams
    • Bug Eric
    • Bug Girl’s Blog
    • Burrard-Lucas Photoblog
    • Catalogue of Organisms
    • Creature Cast
    • Dan Heller
    • Debbie's Insect Blog
    • Dechronization
    • Drawing the MotMot
    • Entomoblog
    • Evolving Thoughts
    • Fall to Climb
    • Generant
    • Historias de Hormigas
    • Life on Six Legs
    • Macromite
    • microecos
    • mirmekolozi
    • myrmecoid
    • Myrmician
    • Natural Imagery
    • Nature in the Ozarks
    • NCSU Insect Blog
    • No Cropping Zone
    • omit needless words
    • Photo Synthesis
    • Princess Peppercloud
    • Science Blogs
    • Snail’s Tales
    • Stu Jenks
    • The Ant Hunter
    • The Ant Room
    • The Bug Whisperer
    • The Loom
    • This Week in Evolution
    • What's Bugging You?
    • Wild about Ants
    • Xenogere
  • Insect Links

    • Ant Farm Forum
    • Ant Insights
    • Antweb
    • Bug Squad
    • bugguide.net
    • Xerces Society
  • Photography Links

    • Canon Photography Forums
    • Digital Photography Review
    • DIY Photography
    • Igor Siwanowicz
    • Mark Plonsky
    • photo.net
    • Piotr Naskrecki
    • The Strobist
  • Popular Posts

    • What does it mean to be an eyeless ant?
    • Must we call them meat ants?
    • Things that look like ants but aren't (Part 2)
    • The Rogue Taxonomist
    • Photo Technique: Working With Ants
    • Speed bumps for our understanding of ant evolution
    • The trouble with phylogenetics
    • Friday Beetle Blogging: Dendroides Larva
    • How to Identify Queen Ants
    • Specimen Request: Army/leafcutter/bullet ant queens for morphometrics
  • Recent Posts

    • This blog has moved.
    • Friday Beetle Blogging: The Hollyhock Weevil
    • The Friday Beetle will be late…
    • Bed bugs reach an all-time high
    • Answer to the Monday Night Mystery
  • Recent Comments

    • Donald Byron Johnson on Reader question: who discovered the sex of ant workers?
    • Anonymous on Update on the Rogue Taxonomist
    • Ant on Arizona Daily Star covers “Planet of the Ants”
    • Ga. Girl on Beware the Cow-Killer
    • Anonymous on Beware the Cow-Killer
  • Categories

  • Archives

  • animation Ants aphids arachnids Argentina arizona army ants art Bees beetles behavior biodiversity biology Biology Links bugs Canon carabidae coleoptera copyright Darwin desert diptera E. O. Wilson ecology entomology Evolution fail fire ants Flies formicidae genetics google haiku Harpegnathos imaging Insect Links Insects invasive species lighting Linepithema macro macrophotography macro photography Martialis media miniscule muppets music myrmecology mystery natural history Nature new species odontomachus Parasites Paratrechina pests pheidole Photography Photography business photoshop phylogenetics phylogeny Pogonomyrmex politics predation Scarabaeidae Science SEM social insects spiders Taxonomy termites travel wasps
  • Nature Blog Network
    Add to Technorati Favorites

    Follow this blog

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

WPThemes.


  • Follow Following
    • Myrmecos Blog
    • Join 91 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Myrmecos Blog
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Copy shortlink
    • Report this content
    • View post in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...
 

    %d bloggers like this: